DATE: 02/25/2005 TIME: 08:13:27
COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS - PROPERTY TAX DIVISION 2004 FIELD STUDIES CATEGORY WORKSHEET 187/Polk 187-907/Livingston ISD
PAGE: 001 REPT: PTS236 VRSN: P
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 2 $ 12,813 - $ 38,874 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ CRYSTAL LAKES NO 1 LT 295 CRYSTAL LAKES NO 3 LTS 71 GREEN ACRES LT 16 INDIAN HILL ESTATES NO 2 INDIAN HILL HEIGHTS NO 1 INDIAN SPRING LAKE NO 11 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N LAKEVIEW NO 2 B 10 LTS 16 MANGUM EST NO 1 LT 271 PINEHILL B 2 LTS 12/13 PUTNAMS LANDING NO 1 LTS PUTNAMS LANDING NO 1 LTS SHELTER COVE NO 3 LT 1 SHELTER COVE S 3 LT 60 TAYLOR LAKE EST NO 6 LT 5 WILD COUNTRY LAKES NO 3 L CHOATE A 15 S 1 PT LT 85 CHOATE A 15 S 1 LOT 90 DIKES A 27 TR 113 ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ C2400012100 C2400026400/26300 G0500001400 I0500017100 I0700006800 I0800085200 L0400000300 L0400001100 L0900009000 M0500015300 & M0500015100 P1200001600 P1700006400 P1700014200 S1100015000 S1100020400 T0200020200 WS/A SALE DATE ___ _________ S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S 05/2003 07/2003 07/2003 03/2003 08/2003 03/2003 03/2003 08/2003 05/2003 10/2003 08/2003 07/2003 04/2003 07/2003 05/2003 01/2004 05/2003 02/2004 02/2003 01/2004 STRATUM 2 TOTALS SALE PRICE __________ 48,000 19,000 25,000 30,000 17,000 9,000 30,000 13,500 10,000 37,500 20,000 12,000 11,000 23,000 16,204 33,000 10,000 34,000 45,000 20,000 LOCAL VALUE ___________ 26,728 15,957 21,363 32,168 20,444 14,332 30,467 29,140 17,340 34,674 21,190 19,077 12,845 24,765 16,437 33,883 13,080 29,045 24,395 19,696 ___________ 457,026 PTD VALUE _________ 48,000 19,000 25,000 30,000 17,000 9,000 30,000 13,500 10,000 37,500 20,000 12,000 11,000 23,000 16,204 33,000 10,000 34,000 45,000 20,000 ___________ 463,204 RATIO _____ 0.5568 0.8398 0.8545 1.0723 1.2026 1.5924 1.0156 2.1585 1.7340 0.9246 1.0595 1.5898 1.1677 1.0767 1.0144 1.0268 1.3080 0.8543 0.5421 0.9848 ______ 0.9867
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 3 $ 38,875 - $ 66,627 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ CHEROKEE FOREST NO 1 LTS CHESSWOOD NO 1 B 2 LT 12 CHESSWOOD NO 2 B 2 LTS 1, FOREST SPRINGS NO 3 LT 10 HOLIDAY LAKE ESTATES NO 4 INDIAN HILL EST NO 2 B 7 INDIAN HILL EST NO 2 B 8 INDIAN HILL HEIGHTS NO 2 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ C0600003800 C0700002600 C0700006400 F0500036800 H1200034600 & H1200034500 I0500026200 I0500028400 I0700016800/16900 L0200019200 S/A SALE DATE ___ _________ S S S S S S S S S 01/2004 04/2003 03/2003 06/2003 11/2003 03/2003 05/2003 07/2003 12/2003 SALE PRICE __________ 52,000 91,000 69,000 80,000 45,000 39,016 65,000 73,000 142,000 LOCAL VALUE ___________ 51,447 53,280 52,750 48,090 45,182 45,312 45,280 51,597 59,958 PTD VALUE _________ 52,000 91,000 69,000 80,000 45,000 39,016 65,000 73,000 142,000 RATIO _____ 0.9894 0.5855 0.7645 0.6011 1.0040 1.1614 0.6966 0.7068 0.4222
PAGE: 002 REPT: PTS236 VRSN: P
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 3 $ 38,875 - $ 66,627 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N MEMORIAL POINT B 1 LTS 8/ MEMORIAL POINT B 10 LT 20 MEMORIAL POINT TWN HSE NO OAK TERRACE EST NO 4 LT 3 SHELTER COVE NO 5 B 2 L SHELTER COVE NO 5 B 2 LTS SIESTA COUNTRY NO 2 LT 38 SUNSET SHADOWS NO 1 LT 54 FALCON A 32 TR 98 LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO ___________ _________ _____ 49,903 50,000 0.9981 63,920 62,000 1.0310 57,022 71,000 0.8031 42,452 35,000 1.2129 51,425 53,200 0.9666 56,461 60,450 0.9340 60,580 85,000 0.7127 48,261 41,000 1.1771 47,460 42,000 1.1300 48,774 50,000 0.9755 61,498 40,000 1.5375 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 1,040,652 1,245,666 0.8354 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 4 $ 66,628 - $ 109,408 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ BAY HAVEN NO 1 B 2 LTS 16 BRIARBEND NO 1 LT 52 CAMPBELL-WOOD LT 22 CHESSWOOD NO 1 B 5 L 1 & CHESSWOOD NO 2 B 1 LT 1 CRESCENT SHORES B 9 LT 4 CRESCENT SHORES B 9 LT 33 FOREST SPRINGS NO 3 LT 7 INDIAN HILL EST NO 1 B 4 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 1 LAKE LIVINGSTON ESTS NO 1 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 LAKEWOOD NO 2 LT 11 MEMORIAL POINT B 9 LT 53 OAK FOREST B 5 LOT 4 PINEHILL B 1 PT OF LTS 1 SCHWAB CITY ACRES TR 11 TEXAS LANDING LT 31/32 TEXAS LANDING LOT 103 TEXAS LANDING LT 115 THUNDER MTN LAKES NO 1 B BURRIS A 10 TR 32-L HAMPTON A 280 TR 3A SMITH A 820 S 4 TR 44 ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ B0200004500 B1000004900 C0150002200 C0700004200 C0700005500 AND C07000056 C2200009700 C2200012500 F0500038500 I050008000 L0200007500 L0200009100 L0200022400 L1000003900 M1400041900 O0100005200 P1200000100 S0400001200 T0425003100/003200 T0425010300 T0425011500 TS/A SALE DATE ___ _________ S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S 06/2003 02/2003 02/2003 05/2003 03/2003 11/2003 01/2003 03/2003 06/2003 05/2003 02/2004 09/2003 11/2003 04/2003 01/2003 02/2003 03/2003 09/2003 08/2003 10/2003 03/2003 09/2003 05/2003 05/2003 STRATUM 4 TOTALS SALE PRICE __________ 110,000 75,000 86,500 90,100 69,650 125,500 125,000 69,000 145,000 61,000 110,000 58,000 75,000 69,000 89,900 65,000 80,000 113,000 127,500 77,500 62,000 68,950 53,000 42,000 LOCAL VALUE ___________ 107,350 75,680 85,600 90,280 69,183 96,234 69,076 78,561 103,412 67,952 67,534 71,164 75,178 72,153 81,226 67,755 70,117 92,740 93,179 68,549 68,215 86,005 67,517 71,594 ___________ 1,896,254 PTD VALUE _________ 110,000 75,000 86,500 90,100 69,650 125,500 125,000 69,000 145,000 61,000 110,000 58,000 75,000 69,000 89,900 65,000 80,000 113,000 127,500 77,500 62,000 68,950 53,000 42,000 ___________ 2,047,600 RATIO _____ 0.9759 1.0091 0.9896 1.0020 0.9933 0.7668 0.5526 1.1386 0.7132 1.1140 0.6139 1.2270 1.0024 1.0457 0.9035 1.0424 0.8765 0.8207 0.7308 0.8845 1.1002 1.2474 1.2739 1.7046 ______ 0.9261 ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ L0400000700 L0400201700 M1400001500 M1400044700 M1500004400 O0300021700/22200 S1100047300 S1100050400 S1300012700 AND S13000129 SS/A SALE DATE ___ _________ S 05/2003 S 08/2003 S 07/2003 S 11/2003 S 06/2003 S 09/2003 S 12/2003 S 09/2003 S 02/2003 S 12/2003 S 03/2004 SALE PRICE __________ 50,000 62,000 71,000 35,000 53,200 60,450 85,000 41,000 42,000 50,000 40,000

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
PAGE: 003 REPT: PTS236 VRSN: P
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - STRATUM 5 $ 109,409 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ BRIARBEND NO 1 LTS 29/30 COMMODORE CAPE S 2 LT 59 COMMODORE CAPE S 2 LOT 11 COUNTRY CHARM TR 3 DAVIS WOODS B 1 L 9 ENCHNTED FOREST LT 45 ENCHANTED FOREST NO 2 LT INDIAN HILL NO 2 B 16 LT INDIAN HILL EST NO 3 LT 4 INDIAN HILLS EATATES NO 3 INDIAN HILL HEIGHTS NO 1 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 2 LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 PINE VALLEY LT 9 PINE VALLEY LT 18 - 20 SUNSET SHADOWS NO 2 LT 6 TEXAS LANDING LT 60 CHOATE A 15 TR 144C ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ B1000002800 C1200005900 C1200010700 C1625000101 D0150000900 E0800004200 E0800008800 I0400042800 I0500036500 I0500040600 I0700003000 L0200016700 L0200036400 P0900000900 P090001900/2000/2100 S300002600 TS/A SALE DATE ___ _________ S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S 06/2003 09/2003 01/2003 11/2003 03/2004 03/2003 07/2003 03/2003 08/2003 01/2003 08/2003 10/2003 12/2003 02/2003 08/2003 04/2003 12/2003 02/2003 STRATUM 5 TOTALS SALE PRICE __________ 140,000 220,000 230,000 115,000 140,000 170,000 180,000 145,000 192,500 110,000 130,000 195,000 215,000 163,900 153,000 98,500 249,500 333,000 LOCAL VALUE ___________ 145,873 172,984 144,386 138,787 145,514 160,574 141,862 185,081 181,064 113,135 127,596 140,804 138,998 162,813 113,455 118,670 172,581 326,733 ___________ 2,830,910 PTD VALUE _________ 140,000 220,000 230,000 115,000 140,000 170,000 180,000 145,000 192,500 110,000 130,000 195,000 215,000 163,900 153,000 98,500 249,500 333,000 ___________ 3,180,400 RATIO _____ 1.0420 0.7863 0.6278 1.2068 1.0394 0.9446 0.7881 1.2764 0.9406 1.0285 0.9815 0.7221 0.6465 0.9934 0.7415 1.2048 0.6917 0.9812 ______ 0.8901
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY A - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM _______ COMP ____ CODE ____ U R R R R SAMPLE ______ PARCELS _______ 18 STRATUM _______ PARCELS _______ 3,034 3,566 1,686 1,SAMPLE ______ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 0 457,026 1,040,652 1,896,254 2,830,910 SAMPLE ______ PTD VALUE _________ 0 463,204 1,245,666 2,047,600 3,180,400 STRATUM _______ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 18,828,716 89,484,485 89,434,445 89,445,872 89,467,277 STRATUM _______ RATIO _____ 0.9867 0.8354 0.9261 0.8901 STRATUM _______ PTD VALUE _________ 18,828,716 90,690,671 107,055,836 96,583,384 100,513,737 CATEGORY ________ RATIO _____
TOTAL 82 9,851 6,224,842 6,936,870 376,660,795 413,672,344 0.9105 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

PAGE: 004 REPT: PTS236 VRSN: P
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 2 $ 1,558 - $ 5,754 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ CHEROKEE FOREST NO 1 LT 7 COUNTRY CHARM TR 2 A 408 FOREST SPRINGS NO 2 B D L FOREST SPRINGS NO 3 LT 28 FOREST SPRINGS NO 4 LT 11 HOLLY HILLS NO 1 BLK 4 LT LAKE LIVINGSTON EST NO 3 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N MEMORIAL POINT B 1 LT 4 MEMORIAL POINT B 2 LT 27 MEMORIAL POINT B 5 LT 2 MEMORIAL POINT B 10 LT 10 OAK TERRACE EST NO 5 LT 4 OAK TERRACE EST NO 6 LT 5 OAK TERRACE EST NO 3 LT 4 REILYS LANDING LTS 229/23 SHILOH RIDGE LT 7 AND PT SPRING CREEK NO 2 LT 7 TAYLOR LAKE EST NO 6 LT 4 WIGGINS VILLAGE S 2 LTS 1 PRICE A 720 TR 1YY BEECH ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ C0600006600 C1625000100 F0500031900 F0500036001 F0500045900 H1500004800 L0200030200 L04000202400 M1400001100 M1400005100 M1400019300 M1400043700 O0300026700 O0300028400 O030017100 R0500013005 S1200005900 S1950006000 T0200019505 WS/A SALE DATE ___ _________ S 07/2003 S 06/2003 S 02/2003 S 11/2003 S 06/2003 S 03/2003 S 09/2003 S 08/2003 S 02/2003 S 11/2003 S 08/2003 S 04/2003 S 08/2003 S 11/2003 S 01/2004 S 08/2003 S 06/2003 S 03/2003 S 01/2003 S 02/2004 S 01/2003 SALE PRICE __________ 2,000 6,000 3,500 3,000 2,670 1,500 4,400 2,000 1,500 2,500 1,000 1,080 3,600 1,500 5,000 6,470 4,000 1,275 2,500 1,800 2,600 LOCAL VALUE ___________ 3,281 5,241 3,510 2,933 3,200 2,811 4,400 4,150 2,024 2,376 2,173 2,160 3,600 1,680 5,222 5,000 3,938 2,442 1,600 2,000 4,200 ___________ 67,941 PTD VALUE _________ 2,000 6,000 3,500 3,000 2,670 1,500 4,400 2,000 1,500 2,500 1,000 1,080 3,600 1,500 5,000 6,470 4,000 1,275 2,500 1,800 2,600 ___________ 59,895 RATIO _____ 1.6405 0.8735 1.0029 0.9777 1.1985 1.8740 1.0000 2.0750 1.3493 0.9504 2.1730 2.0000 1.0000 1.1200 1.0444 0.7728 0.9845 1.9153 0.6400 1.1111 1.6154 ______ 1.1343

STRATUM 2 TOTALS

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 3 $ 5,755 - $ 14,714 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ ALEXANDER B 2 GARDEN ACRES LT 21-23 HIDDEN VALLEY EST NO 4 B INDIAN HILLS NO 2 B 22 PT INDIAN HILL NO 2 B 22 LT INDIAN HILL ESTATES NO 2 MAXWELL TR 19 OAK FOREST B 8 LT 7 OAK FOREST B 8 LT 10 PUTNAMS LANDING NO 1 LT 2 ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ A0300000100 G0025002100//200/3000 H0800003400 I0400050200 I0400053600 I0500031900/32000 M1100002800 O0100000900 O0100009300 P1700002100 & P1700029800 S/A SALE DATE ___ _________ A S S S A S S A S S 02/2003 05/2003 05/2003 06/2003 05/2003 01/2003 03/2004 SALE PRICE __________ 15,000 4,000 7,000 6,000 7,000 9,000 7,000 LOCAL VALUE ___________ 9,190 13,889 9,384 10,536 5,880 7,680 6,957 11,742 9,981 8,880 PTD VALUE _________ 13,515 15,000 4,000 7,000 4,200 6,000 7,000 8,807 9,000 7,000 RATIO _____ 0.6800 0.9259 2.3460 1.5051 1.4000 1.2800 0.9939 1.3333 1.1090 1.2686

PAGE: 005 REPT: PTS236 VRSN: P
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 3 $ 5,755 - $ 14,714 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ SOUTHLAND PLANTATION S 6 TEMPE TIMBERED TERR NO 1 OAK TERRACE EST NO 3 LTS DIKES A 27 TR 31 LT 24 MILES A 413 TR 27B L 1 MILES A 413 TR 23 LOCAL VALUE PTD VALUE RATIO ___________ _________ _____ 8,668 8,668 1.0000 13,300 13,000 1.0231 6,916 9,000 0.7684 10,037 8,000 1.2546 10,102 3,500 2.8863 10,173 10,000 1.0173 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 153,315 133,690 1.1468 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 4 $ 14,715 - $ 37,800 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ CHESSWOOD NO 1 B 3 L 1 EASTON OAKS LT 12/14 EASTWAY B 12 LTS 1 THRU 3 ENCHANTED FOREST LT 1 TH HIDDEN VALLEY EST NO 2 B INDIAN HILL EST NO 2 B 12 JENNINGS COVE LT 6 JENNINGS COVE LT 12 LAKE LIVINGSTON VILLAGE N RESORT COUNTRY NO 2 LT 30 RESORT COUNTRY S 2 LT 84 TIMBERLAND COVE TR 12 CHOATE A 15 S 1 LUB LT 65 CHOATE A 15 S 4 TR 9 MORGAN A 56 TR 34 PICKNEY A 63 TR 45B ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ C0700003000 E0150001200/1400 E0200002500 E0800000100/200/300/400 H0800001500 I0500035701 J0010000600 J0010001200 L0400195100 R0700006100 R0700010900 T10063005402 S/A SALE DATE ___ _________ A S A S A S S A A A A A A A A A 01/2003 05/2003 01/2003 02/2003 SALE PRICE __________ 21,000 20,000 20,000 15,500 LOCAL VALUE ___________ 26,168 16,601 19,260 24,000 14,954 20,062 30,564 17,391 16,875 35,550 20,250 24,150 17,201 25,842 15,443 28,532 ___________ 352,843 PTD VALUE _________ 36,408 21,000 15,408 20,000 14,910 20,000 15,500 19,323 18,000 23,700 16,200 22,869 19,602 27,565 12,112 45,651 ___________ 348,248 RATIO _____ 0.7187 0.7905 1.2500 1.2000 1.0030 1.0031 1.9719 0.9000 0.9375 1.5000 1.2500 1.0560 0.8775 0.9375 1.2750 0.6250 ______ 1.0132 ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ S1825013500 T1041303100 S/A SALE DATE ___ _________ S 05/2003 S 05/2004 S 02/2003 S 06/2003 S 02/2003 S 04/2004 SALE PRICE __________ 8,668 13,000 9,000 8,000 3,500 10,000

STRATUM 4 TOTALS

PAGE: 006 REPT: PTS236 VRSN: P
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - STRATUM 5 $ 37,801 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ BEACON BAY S 1 L 1 BEACON BAY S 1 LT 2 DEERFIELD LT 2 DEERFIELD LT 12 DICKENS LANDING NO 2 LT 9 INDIAN HILL EST NO 1 B 2 LAKE LIVINGSTON ESTS NO 3 LAKEWOOD LT 22 OAK TERRACE EST NO 1 LT 2 CHOATE A 15 TR 113A-1 VIESCA A 78 TR 15 BRADLEY A 98 TR 24 BRADLEY A 98 TR 26 BRADLEY A 98 TR 27 FERGUSON A 245 TR 10 L 1 HAYNES A 324 TR 1H ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ B0250000100 B0250000200 D0250000200 D0250001200 D0375002900 I0500000110 L0200020800 &L0200020700 L100002100 OS/A SALE DATE ___ _________ S A A A A A S A A A A A A A A A 08/2003 SALE PRICE __________ 55,000 LOCAL VALUE ___________ 78,750 49,613 67,450 45,030 38,968 39,600 38,500 54,780 42,660 113,815 50,400 77,242 67,920 43,080 39,060 60,946 ___________ 907,814 PTD VALUE _________ 55,000 37,800 42,600 23,700 45,844 22,000 38,000 36,155 31,600 100,118 37,800 57,935 59,172 31,276 28,358 73,745 ___________ 721,103 RATIO _____ 1.4318 1.3125 1.5833 1.9000 0.8500 1.8000 1.0132 1.5151 1.3500 1.1368 1.3333 1.3333 1.1478 1.3774 1.3774 0.8264 ______ 1.2589

04/2003

38,000

STRATUM 5 TOTALS

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY C - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM _______ COMP ____ CODE ____ U R R R R SAMPLE ______ PARCELS _______ 16 STRATUM _______ PARCELS _______ 9,159 11,428 3,993 1,SAMPLE ______ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 0 67,941 153,315 352,843 907,814 SAMPLE ______ PTD VALUE _________ 0 59,895 133,690 348,248 721,103 STRATUM _______ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 7,657,353 36,380,304 36,376,461 36,431,931 36,315,866 STRATUM _______ RATIO _____ 1.1343 1.1468 1.0132 1.2589 STRATUM _______ PTD VALUE _________ 7,657,353 32,072,912 31,719,969 35,957,295 28,847,300 CATEGORY ________ RATIO _____
TOTAL 69 26,634 1,481,913 1,262,936 153,161,915 136,254,829 1.1241 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
PAGE: 007 REPT: PTS236 VRSN: P
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY D3 - STRATUM $1 - $99,999,999,ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ C1250000300 O0500000900 P0350000600/ S1825007800 S1825017409 S& S/A SALE DATE ___ _________ A A S 08/2003 S 02/2003 S 01/2003 S 12/2003 S 10/2003 S 02/2003 A A S 02/2003 A A A A A S 06/2003 A A A SALE PRICE __________ 175,000 7,000 22,000 55,000 29,500 8,000 17,000 LOCAL VALUE ___________ 24,806 26,238 182,279 9,474 20,000 52,281 29,523 16,412 61,301 36,323 23,943 182,000 37,466 24,575 23,625 25,976 65,113 24,857 27,619 469,700 ___________ 1,363,511 PTD VALUE _________ 26,250 26,600 175,000 7,000 22,000 55,000 29,500 8,000 59,278 28,885 17,000 182,000 24,818 25,002 24,000 26,219 60,000 26,500 26,000 422,730 ___________ 1,271,782 RATIO _____ 0.9450 0.9864 1.0416 1.3534 0.9091 0.9506 1.0008 2.0515 1.0341 1.2575 1.4084 1.0000 1.5096 0.9829 0.9844 0.9907 1.0852 0.9380 1.0623 1.1111 ______ 1.0721
LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ COPELAND CREEK 113 TR 3 OATES LT 18 PEBBLE CREEK TR 6/141 SOUTHLAND PLANTATION SEC SOUTHLAND PLANTATION SEC SOUTHLAND PLANTATIONS S 2 BURKES A 9 CHOATE A 15 S 1 TR 8 COLLVILLE A 16 TR 2 DIKES A 28 TR 23 HIROMS A 37 TR 37 PARKER A 61 TR 38 VIESCA A 78 WILBURN A 80 TR 15 & 35 JONES A 364 TR 7 MARSH A 445 TR 4 RUDDLE A 516 TR 9 TRACEY A 569 TR 11 & 9 VIESCA A 77 TR 149 POITEVENT A 1016 TR 1

60,000

STRATUM 0 TOTALS
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY D3 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM _______ COMP ____ CODE ____ R SAMPLE ______ PARCELS _______ 20 STRATUM _______ PARCELS _______ 4,071 SAMPLE ______ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 1,363,511 SAMPLE ______ PTD VALUE _________ 1,271,782 STRATUM _______ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 64,437,479 STRATUM _______ RATIO _____ 1.0721 STRATUM _______ PTD VALUE _________ 60,103,982 CATEGORY ________ RATIO _____
TOTAL 20 4,071 1,363,511 1,271,782 64,437,479 60,103,982 1.0721 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
PAGE: 008 REPT: PTS236 VRSN: P
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 2 $ 29,532 - $ 136,111 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ LIVINGSTON OT B 20 LTS 3/ MILLS FOREST LT 9 & 9 SF SPRING CREEK BUSINESS PAR SPRING CREEK BUSINESS PAR TH;UNDER MTN LAKES NO 1 B CHOATE A 15 S 1 CA & SUB CHAOTE A 15 PT S 2 SUB LO CHOATE A 15 S 3 TR 5B MORGAN A 56 TR 21 MORGAN A 56 PT TR 36 PICKNEY A 63 TR 25 VIESCA A 78 TR 60-C FERGUSON A 245 TR 3B HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10B ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ L1400005900 M1700000900 S196001300 S196002150 TS/A SALE DATE ___ _________ A A A A A A A A A A A A A A SALE PRICE __________ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 92,082 79,083 46,349 54,696 109,650 87,623 73,648 77,582 104,325 47,269 105,198 71,993 56,104 128,701 ___________ 1,134,303 PTD VALUE _________ 79,664 97,027 49,015 57,354 173,429 59,483 109,105 58,896 125,028 39,628 153,540 89,826 25,840 206,719 ___________ 1,324,554 RATIO _____ 1.1559 0.8151 0.9456 0.9537 0.6322 1.4731 0.6750 1.3173 0.8344 1.1928 0.6852 0.8015 2.1712 0.6226 ______ 0.8564
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 3 $ 136,112 - $ 386,295 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ ENCHANTED FOREST LT 70 LAKESIDE B 3 PT OF 2 ALL LIVINGSTON OT B 26 LT 4A, NORTH PT B E PT LTS 5 AND CHOATE A 15 TR 130 CHOATE A 15 TR 168C LT 3 CHOATE A 15 S 2 SUB LT 1 CHOATE A 15 S 2 SUB LOT P CHOATE A 15 S 4 PT TR 3 BBB&CRR A 153 TRS 4 AND 5 HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10A HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10 HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10J ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ E0800006700 L0700000400 L1400008600 NS/A SALE DATE ___ _________ A A A A A A A A A A A A A SALE PRICE __________ LOCAL VALUE ___________ PTD VALUE _________ RATIO _____

220,052 205,825 1.0691 266,779 241,928 1.1027 176,605 116,964 1.5099 260,337 191,410 1.3601 144,420 150,137 0.9619 261,534 286,940 0.9115 190,818 250,829 0.7607 223,875 246,915 0.9067 224,842 270,081 0.8325 168,468 167,778 1.0041 221,608 157,784 1.4045 229,098 251,383 0.9114 321,338 244,826 1.3125 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 2,909,774 2,782,800 1.0456 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 4 $ 386,296 - $ 1,183,570 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ MILLS FOREST LT 1 ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ M1700000100 S/A SALE DATE ___ _________ A SALE PRICE __________ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 1,177,281 PTD VALUE _________ 1,461,895 RATIO _____ 0.8053
PAGE: 009 REPT: PTS236 VRSN: P
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 4 $ 386,296 - $ 1,183,570 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ CHOATE A 15 TR 110A (IMP CHOATE A 15 PT TR 112 CHOATE A 15 TR 122 CHOATE A 15 TR 127B HEB GROCERY CO CHOATE A 15 TR 169 CHOATE A 15 TRS 171A AND CHOATE A 15 PT S 1 LT 150 CHOATE A 15 S 2 SUB LT 59 CHOATE A 15 S 2 SUB LOTS CHOATE A 15 S 3 PT SUB LO HICKS A 282 PT TR 9 & 10H ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ S/A SALE DATE ___ _________ A A A A A S 10/2003 A A S 02/2004 A A A SALE PRICE __________ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 549,086 493,052 895,081 509,902 845,229 1,086,370 463,154 433,042 430,246 517,718 812,506 524,333 ___________ 8,737,000 PTD VALUE _________ 451,946 945,230 1,001,541 460,928 665,861 697,451 316,511 420,430 430,000 399,590 1,009,168 770,278 ___________ 9,030,829 RATIO _____ 1.2149 0.5216 0.8937 1.1063 1.2694 1.5576 1.4633 1.0300 1.0006 1.2956 0.8051 0.6807 ______ 0.9675

697,451 430,000

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - STRATUM 5 $ 1,183,571 - $999,999,999 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ LIVINGSTON VENTURES CHOATE A 15 TR 121-A CHOATE A 15 TR 163C CHOATE A 15 TR 168 CHOATE A 15 S 3 PT LT 18A ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ 10015057301 S/A SALE DATE ___ _________ A A A A A STRATUM 5 TOTALS SALE PRICE __________ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 1,852,001 7,408,436 1,298,425 3,510,787 1,739,955 ___________ 15,809,604 PTD VALUE _________ 2,548,845 7,108,166 1,035,112 4,770,763 2,493,024 ___________ 17,955,910 RATIO _____ 0.7266 1.0422 1.2544 0.7359 0.6979 ______ 0.8805
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY F1 - TOTALS ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ STRATUM _______ COMP ____ CODE ____ U R R R R SAMPLE ______ PARCELS _______ 5 STRATUM _______ PARCELS _______ 8 SAMPLE ______ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 0 1,134,303 2,909,774 8,737,000 15,809,604 SAMPLE ______ PTD VALUE _________ 0 1,324,554 2,782,800 9,030,829 17,955,910 STRATUM _______ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 4,468,255 21,392,636 21,150,759 22,405,438 20,176,164 STRATUM _______ RATIO _____ 0.8564 1.0456 0.9675 0.8805 STRATUM _______ PTD VALUE _________ 4,468,255 24,979,724 20,228,346 23,158,075 22,914,440 CATEGORY ________ RATIO _____

TOTAL 28,590,681 31,094,093 89,593,252 95,748,840 0.9357 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
PAGE: 010 REPT: PTS236 VRSN: P
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 2 $ 10,551 - $ 61,364 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ TOYOTA MOTOR CREDIT CORP RICK'S RECREATIONAL VEHIC COUNTRY COTTAGE GE CAPITAL SUMMIT FUNDING WESTAR LEASE ORIGINATION UHAUL INTERNATIONAL FRITO-LAY INC SUBWAY SNADWICHES DE LAGE LANDEN OPERATIONA ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ BP000774600 BP001184600 BP002037500 BP002072300 BP003199400 BP003232109 BP200213605 BP920068000 BP970736300 BP980207591 S/A SALE DATE ___ _________ A A A A A A A A A A SALE PRICE __________ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 25,917 34,984 25,000 25,488 27,235 14,750 27,618 11,934 22,733 19,280 ___________ 234,939 PTD VALUE _________ 27,071 17,408 25,270 24,466 23,045 33,963 58,981 11,934 17,920 74,835 ___________ 314,893 RATIO _____ 0.9574 2.0097 0.9893 1.0418 1.1818 0.4343 0.4683 1.0000 1.2686 0.2576 ______ 0.7461
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 3 $ 61,365 - $ 235,333 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ PINE RIDGE NURSING HOME MOBILE SUN MART FORD MOTOR CREDIT LIVINGSTON JEWELRY COMPAN OWEN FURNITURE PETROLEUM WHOLESALE CONVE FIRST STATE BANK - WESTSI TEXAS PEPPER RESTAURANT PITNEY BOWES CREDIT CORP ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ BP000104000 BP000215010 BP000272001 BP000471000 BP000576000 BP000599500 BP200064700 BP930202500 BP970165413 S/A SALE DATE ___ _________ A A A A A A A A A SALE PRICE __________ LOCAL VALUE ___________ PTD VALUE _________ RATIO _____
203,487 190,071 1.0706 68,500 55,484 1.2346 127,525 83,190 1.5329 72,244 90,736 0.7962 224,779 137,200 1.6383 144,057 78,053 1.8456 79,794 86,947 0.9177 75,259 85,805 0.8771 99,997 86,158 1.1606 ___________ ___________ ______ STRATUM 3 TOTALS 1,095,642 893,644 1.2260 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CATEGORY L1 - STRATUM 4 $ 235,334 - $ 1,011,513 LEGAL DESCRIPTION _________________ BASKINS DEPARTMENT STORE RED BARN BUILDERS SUPPLY SAM HOUSTON ELECTRIC COOP SMITH AND SONS GRAVEL AUTOZONE ORILEY AUTO PARTS DOLLAR GENERAL ACCOUNT NUMBER ______________ BP000044500 BP000644300 BP000668000 BP0006965 BP001019100 BP002158500 BP9600047800 S/A SALE DATE ___ _________ A A A A A A A STRATUM 4 TOTALS SALE PRICE __________ LOCAL VALUE ___________ 414,631 606,555 849,054 255,070 423,566 381,836 258,484 ___________ 3,189,196 PTD VALUE _________ 415,837 518,791 834,639 269,027 434,096 202,005 267,720 ___________ 2,942,115 RATIO _____ 0.9971 1.1692 1.0173 0.9481 0.9757 1.8902 0.9655 ______ 1.0840